73,385
edits
Evaluate the Evidence: Difference between revisions
fix cat
(change URL Ken Smith) |
(fix cat) |
||
| Line 47: | Line 47: | ||
*'''''Original records''''' tend to be more accurate than derivative records. They were written close in time to the events they record. However, on occasion the recorder may have made a mistake. Infrequently an original record is deliberately falsified, such as "back dating" a marriage to account for the early birth of the first child. Even a source recorded close to the time of the event may have errors. | *'''''Original records''''' tend to be more accurate than derivative records. They were written close in time to the events they record. However, on occasion the recorder may have made a mistake. Infrequently an original record is deliberately falsified, such as "back dating" a marriage to account for the early birth of the first child. Even a source recorded close to the time of the event may have errors. | ||
*'''''Derivative records''''' tend to be easier to use and contain more information. However, they represent a reiteration of information from one or more other sources. The author may not have had enough information to adequately interpret the other sources. On the other hand, the compiler may have known of errors in the other sources and corrected or explained them in the compilation.<br> | *'''''Derivative records''''' tend to be easier to use and contain more information. However, they represent a reiteration of information from one or more other sources. The author may not have had enough information to adequately interpret the other sources. On the other hand, the compiler may have known of errors in the other sources and corrected or explained them in the compilation.<br> | ||
*'''''Finding aids''''' sometimes contain mistakes that can mislead the researcher, such as wrong page numbers in an index. | *'''''Finding aids''''' sometimes contain mistakes that can mislead the researcher, such as wrong page numbers in an index. | ||
*'''''Background information''''' is sometimes misinterpreted or applied incorrectly to individual cases. For example, just because most immigrants joined friends or relatives in their new country does not mean your ancestor had relatives when he arrived in his new country. | *'''''Background information''''' is sometimes misinterpreted or applied incorrectly to individual cases. For example, just because most immigrants joined friends or relatives in their new country does not mean your ancestor had relatives when he arrived in his new country. | ||
| Line 54: | Line 54: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| bgcolor="#ffff99" align="center" | | | bgcolor="#ffff99" align="center" | | ||
'''Even a source recorded close to the time of the event may have errors.''' | '''Even a source recorded close to the time of the event may have errors.''' | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 68: | Line 68: | ||
A key to interpreting information is determining how close in time it was recorded to the event it describes. ''Information'' is the statement(s) of fact(s) in a record, not the record itself. It is either primary or secondary. | A key to interpreting information is determining how close in time it was recorded to the event it describes. ''Information'' is the statement(s) of fact(s) in a record, not the record itself. It is either primary or secondary. | ||
'''''Primary Information''''' was recorded at or near the time of the event by someone closely associated with it. It is usually found in original records. However, ''not'' all information in an original record is "primary." For example, a death record usually contains primary information about the death, but secondary information about the person's birth. If the information does not come from a primary account of the event, consider it suspect. If you cannot determine where the information originated, it is undocumented, and therefore less reliable information.<br> | '''''Primary Information''''' was recorded at or near the time of the event by someone closely associated with it. It is usually found in original records. However, ''not'' all information in an original record is "primary." For example, a death record usually contains primary information about the death, but secondary information about the person's birth. If the information does not come from a primary account of the event, consider it suspect. If you cannot determine where the information originated, it is undocumented, and therefore less reliable information.<br> | ||
{| style="width: 221px; height: 34px" border="1" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" align="center" | {| style="width: 221px; height: 34px" border="1" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" align="center" | ||
| Line 182: | Line 182: | ||
{{Principles}} | {{Principles}} | ||
[[Category:FamilySearch_Research_Classes_Online]] [[Category:Use_the_Information| | [[Category:FamilySearch_Research_Classes_Online]] [[Category:Use_the_Information|Evaluate the Evidence]] [[Category:Research_Analysis|Research_Analysis]] | ||