Jump to content

FamilySearch Wiki:How Community Governs Wikipedia: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 15: Line 15:
*User oversight, a well-written summary of why many editors produce content that increasingly approaches truth. Includes great quotes from Linus Torvalds, IBM, and John Stuart Mill.
*User oversight, a well-written summary of why many editors produce content that increasingly approaches truth. Includes great quotes from Linus Torvalds, IBM, and John Stuart Mill.


Category:Wikipedia guidelines
Category:Wikipedia guidelines  


Category:Wikipedia official policy
Category:Wikipedia official policy  


Wikipedia:3O (third opinion)  
Wikipedia:3O (third opinion)  
Line 27: Line 27:
Wikipedia:Arbitration committee  
Wikipedia:Arbitration committee  


Wikipedia:Avoid instruction creep
Wikipedia:Avoid instruction creep  


Wikipedia:BB (be bold)  
Wikipedia:BB (be bold)  


Wikipedia:Citing sources
Wikipedia:Citing sources  


Wikipedia:Conflict of interest  
Wikipedia:Conflict of interest  
Line 39: Line 39:
Wikipedia:Dispute resolution   
Wikipedia:Dispute resolution   


Wikipedia:Disrupt
Wikipedia:Disrupt  


Wikipedia:Don't be a fanatic
Wikipedia:Don't be a fanatic  


Wikipedia:Don't disrupt Wikipedia to prove a point
Wikipedia:Don't disrupt Wikipedia to prove a point  


Wikipedia:Edit war
Wikipedia:Edit war  


Wikipedia:Five Pillars
Wikipedia:Five Pillars  


Wikipedia:Forking  
Wikipedia:Forking  


Wikipedia:Game
Wikipedia:Game  


Wikipedia:Help desk  
Wikipedia:Help desk  


Wikipedia:Ignore all rules
Wikipedia:Ignore all rules  


Wikipedia:NPOV (neutral point of view)  
Wikipedia:NPOV (neutral point of view)  
Line 69: Line 69:
Wikipedia:RfM (request for mediation)  
Wikipedia:RfM (request for mediation)  


Wikipedia:The rules are principles
Wikipedia:The rules are principles  


Wikipedia:Single-purpose account  
Wikipedia:Single-purpose account  
Line 77: Line 77:
Wikipedia:Vandalism  
Wikipedia:Vandalism  


Wikipedia:Verifiability
Wikipedia:Verifiability  


Wikipedia:Village pump  
Wikipedia:Village pump  


Wikipedia:Wikilawyering
Wikipedia:Wikilawyering  


Wikipedia:Wikiproject  
Wikipedia:Wikiproject  
Line 169: Line 169:
=== There is no inner circle&nbsp;of editors<ref name="WiSt" />  ===
=== There is no inner circle&nbsp;of editors<ref name="WiSt" />  ===


....Another aspect is that because of the wide-open nature of the editorial process, there is no bottleneck of control through which the content can readily be controlled or massaged by any given individual or interest group. As well, all edits and actions, including past historical versions, are visible to all editors. The Wiki model itself mitigates extremely strongly against control of articles being manipulated by any one interest group, as there are no obvious applicable points of weakness or "approved circle", through which editorial decisions must pass. As a result, maintaining vandalism or a specific viewpoint is all but impossible in the long term, and Wikipedia is extremely resilient long-term against bias, censorship, or manipulation of its articles.
....Another aspect is that because of the wide-open nature of the editorial process, there is no bottleneck of control through which the content can readily be controlled or massaged by any given individual or interest group. As well, all edits and actions, including past historical versions, are visible to all editors. The Wiki model itself mitigates extremely strongly against control of articles being manipulated by any one interest group, as there are no obvious applicable points of weakness or "approved circle", through which editorial decisions must pass. As a result, maintaining vandalism or a specific viewpoint is all but impossible in the long term, and Wikipedia is extremely resilient long-term against bias, censorship, or manipulation of its articles.  


=== Miscellaneous items ===
=== Miscellaneous items ===


*Editors who disagree are unable to write alternative articles or versions to express their differing viewpoints. Ultimately there is only one page upon which all must edit.<ref name="WiSt">from "The wiki structure" in Wikipedia:Editorial oversight and control at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Editorial_oversight_and_control</ref>
*Editors who disagree are unable to write alternative articles or versions to express their differing viewpoints. Ultimately there is only one page upon which all must edit.<ref name="WiSt">from "The wiki structure" in Wikipedia:Editorial oversight and control at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Editorial_oversight_and_control</ref>


== Ahas ==
== Ahas ==


#Wikipedia's policies are vetted and community-approved before becoming policies. So it seems there should be some way of requesting that an idea become policy, so that the community can be flagged and can vet the idea.
#Wikipedia's policies are vetted and community-approved before becoming policies. So it seems there should be some way of requesting that an idea become policy, so that the community can be flagged and can vet the idea.
4,497

edits