Doing Research in Real Time: Difference between revisions

From FamilySearch Wiki
m (Text replacement - "ancestryinstitution" to "ancestry")
(Add affiliate table)
(25 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{NGS2010 | title = Doing Research in Real Time-An Exhilarating Collaboration Experience! | id = F308 | presenter = [[User:MannAE|Alan E. Mann]], <small>AG<sup>®</sup></small>, [[User:RaymondRS|Robert Raymond]], and [[User:RencherDE|David E. Rencher]], <small>AG<sup>®</sup>, CG<sup>SM</sup>, FIGRS, FUGA</small> }}  
{{NGS2010 | title = Doing Research in Real Time-An Exhilarating Collaboration Experience! | id = F308 | presenter = [[User:Alan|Alan E. Mann]], <small>AG<sup>®</sup></small>, [[User:RaymondRS|Robert Raymond]], and David E. Rencher, <small>AG<sup>®</sup>, CG<sup>SM</sup>, FIGRS, FUGA</small> }}  


This session illustrates how to do research collaboratively in real time using off-the-shelf products and services to accomplish more in less time and (we think) better results. FamilySearch has produced a video adaptation of this session. In the Learning Center, see "{{LearningCenter2|328|Doing Research in Real Time: A Collaborative Approach}}."<br>  
This session illustrates how to do research collaboratively in real time using off-the-shelf products and services to accomplish more in less time and (we think) better results.<br>  


= Collaboration  =
= Collaboration  =
Line 9: Line 9:
= Tools for Real-time Collaboration  =
= Tools for Real-time Collaboration  =


We've divided real-time collaboration tools into three types: communication, artifact storage, and aggregation.
<br>


== Communication  ==
== Communication  ==
Line 25: Line 25:
= Tool Tables  =
= Tool Tables  =


Additions and corrections to these tables are encouraged. To qualify for inclusion, a tool must either be free or [[FamilySearch Certified|FamilySearch Certified]]. Since the printing of the syllabus, MyFamily.com eliminated a free offering, so it has been removed from the table.<br>
Additions and corrections to these tables are encouraged. To qualify for inclusion, a tool must either be free or be [[FamilySearch Certified|FamilySearch Certified]].  


The tables in the conference syllabus use the term ''Tree Results'' instead of ''Aggregator''. The tables here have been corrected. The conference syllabus only includes aggregators that provided their own collaborative tree. However, products certified to update the new FamilySearch Tree may be added to the tables below.  
The tables in the conference syllabus use the term ''Tree Results'' instead of ''Aggregator''. The tables here have been corrected. The conference syllabus only includes aggregators that provided their own collaborative tree. However, products certified to update the new FamilySearch Tree may be added to the tables below.  


We invite everyone to monitor or contribute to the real-time research during the conference session. Tools and session participation links are subject to change. Check here before the session for the latest plans.
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1" align="center" style=""
|+
== Collaboration Tools from Google  ==
== Collaboration Tools from Google  ==
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1" align="center"
 
|+
 
 
|-
|-
! scope="col" | Tool<br>  
! scope="col" | Tool<br>  
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>  
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>  
! scope="col" | Session Participation Link<br>
! scope="col" | Cost<br>  
! scope="col" | Cost<br>  
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
|-
|-
| [http://www.blogger.com/ Google Blogger]<br>  
| [http://www.blogger.com/ Google Blogger]<br>  
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Communication Artifacts<br>
| align="center" | [http://ngs2010x.blogspot.com/ NGS2010X Blog] or [mailto:Robert.Raymond.NGS2010X@blogger.com E-mail]<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| HTML and images. Picasa has 1 GB free storage space.<br>
| HTML and images. Picasa has 1 GB limit.<br>
|-
|-
| [http://groups.google.com/ Google Groups<br>]  
| [http://groups.google.com/ Google Groups<br>]  
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Communication Artifacts<br>
| align="center" | <br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Provides messaging and a file area for any file type. Uses upload throttling and 100 MB storage space.<br>
| Provides messaging and a file area for any file type. Uses upload throttling. 100 MB limit.<br>
|-
|-
| [http://docs.google.com/ Google Drive] <br>  
| [http://docs.google.com/ Google Docs]<br>  
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Communication Artifacts<br>
| align="center" | [http://docs.google.com/leaf?id=0B6SYSoDZfwK4MTI1NTFiMWItOWZlMS00MmZkLWFiNmMtMTE0YzNlMDY2ODBk&hl=en Web Link]<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Store any file type. 5 GB storage space.<br>
| Store any file type. 1 GB limit.<br>
|-
|-
| [http://mail.google.com/ Google Gmail]<br>  
| [http://mail.google.com/ Google Gmail]<br>  
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Communication Artifacts<br>
| align="center" | <br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Messages are private. Free storage space is 10 GB.<br><br>
| Messages are private. Free storage space is 7 GB+.<br><br>
|-
|-
| [http://wave.google.com/ Google Blogs]<br>  
| [http://wave.google.com/ Google Wave]<br>  
| align="center" |   Blog Communication<br>  
| align="center" | &nbsp;?<br>
| align="center" | <br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Up to 100 blogs per account.<br>
| &nbsp;?<br>
|-
|-
| [https://tools.google.com/dlpage/hangoutplugin Google Hangouts]<br>  
| [http://mail.google.com/ Google Buzz]<br>  
| align="center" | Chat, Voice, Video Conferencing<br>  
| align="center" | Communication Artifacts<br>
| align="center" | <br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Cloud Storage supplied by Google Drive, YouTube<br>
| Like Gmail, but messages can be shared. Same filesize limit as Gmail: 7 GB+.<br>
|-
|-
| [http://picasaweb.google.com/ Google Picasa]<br>  
| [http://picasaweb.google.com/ Google Picasa]<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | <br>
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| 1 GB storage space.<br>
| 1 GB limit.<br>
|}
|}


== Collaboration Tools from FamilySearch  ==
<br>
 
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1" align="center"
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1" align="center"
|+  
|+  
== Collaboration Tools from FamilySearch  ==
|-
|-
! scope="col" | Tool<br>  
! scope="col" | Tool<br>  
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>  
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>  
! scope="col" | Session Participation Link<br>
! scope="col" | Cost<br>  
! scope="col" | Cost<br>  
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
Line 85: Line 104:
| [http://wiki.familysearch.org/ FamilySearch Wiki]<br>  
| [http://wiki.familysearch.org/ FamilySearch Wiki]<br>  
| align="center" | See notes<br>  
| align="center" | See notes<br>  
| align="center" | [{{fullurl:{{PAGENAME}}}} {{fullurl:{{PAGENAME}}}}]<br>
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Textual information about locations and records can be entered into the wiki. Information about individuals and families can not.<br>
| Textual information about locations and records can be entered into the wiki. Information about individuals and families should not.<br>
|-
|-
| FamilySearch Forums (beta)<br>  
| [http://forums.familysearch.org/ FamilySearch Forums] (beta)<br>  
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Communication Artifacts<br>
| align="center" | Search for tag: NGS2010X<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| jpeg file size limited to 976 KB, other image formats are limited to 620 x 280 pixels.<br>
| jpeg limited to 976 KB, other image formats are limited to 620 x 280.<br>
|-
|-
| [http://new.familysearch.org new FamilySearch] Tree<br>  
| [http://new.familysearch.org New FamilySearch] Tree*<br>  
| align="center" | <br>Aggregation<br><br>  
| align="center" | <br>Aggregation<br> <br>
| align="center" | <br>  
| Free<br>  
| Free<br>  
| Gradual release to the general public sometime in 2010.<br>
| <br>
|}
|}


== Collaboration Tools from Certified FamilySearch Affiliates  ==
&nbsp; * Not available to the general public until the months following the conference<br>
 
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1"
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1"
|+  
|+  
== Collaboration Tools from Certified FamilySearch Affiliates  ==
|-
|-
! scope="col" | Tool<br>  
! scope="col" | Tool<br>  
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>  
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>  
! scope="col" | Session Participation Link<br>
! scope="col" | Cost<br>  
! scope="col" | Cost<br>  
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
Line 110: Line 138:
| [http://www.ancquest.com/aq_collab.htm Ancestral Quest NetFam]<br>  
| [http://www.ancquest.com/aq_collab.htm Ancestral Quest NetFam]<br>  
| align="center" | Aggregation<br>  
| align="center" | Aggregation<br>  
| <br>
| align="center" | $29.95<br>  
| align="center" | $29.95<br>  
| Online tree uses check-in/check-out to a desktop application.<br>
| Online tree uses check-in/check-out to a desktop application<br>
|-
|-
| [http://www.appletree.com Appletree]<br>  
| [http://www.appletree.com Appletree]<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts, Aggregation<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts Aggregation<br>
| <br>  
| align="center" | $59.40/yr<br>  
| align="center" | $59.40/yr<br>  
| <br>
| <br>
|-
|-
| [http://www.arcalife.com Arcalife]<br>  
| [http://www.arcalife.com Arcalife]<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts, Aggregation<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts Aggregation<br>
| <br>  
| align="center" | Free or $250<br>  
| align="center" | Free or $250<br>  
| Limited or 10 GB storage space. [This site can no longer be found.  The last reference to it on the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine is September 2012.]<br>
| limited or 10 GB<br>
|-
|-
| [http://www.familypursuit.com/ FamilyPursuit]<br>  
| [http://www.familypursuit.com/ FamilyPursuit]<br>  
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts,† Aggregation<br>  
| align="center" | Communication Artifacts† Aggregation<br>
| <br>  
| align="center" | Free or<br>† 59.95/yr<br>  
| align="center" | Free or<br>† 59.95/yr<br>  
| 1 GB storage space. <br>† Storing artifacts requires a subscription of 59.95/yr.<br>
| 1 GB<br>
|-
|-
| [http://www.mobiletree.me/ Mobiletree]<br>  
| [http://www.mobiletree.me/ Mobiletree]<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts*<br>
| align="center" | $9.99 <br>  
| <br>  
| iPhone application. Requires an account for the new FamilySearch tree. Accounts will be available to the general public gradually, starting sometime in 2010.<br>
| align="center" | $4.99 <br>  
| iPhone application<br>
|-
|-
| [http://www.onegreatfamily.com/ One Great Family]<br>  
| [http://www.onegreatfamily.com/ One Great Family]<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts, Aggregation<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts Aggregation<br>
| <br>  
| align="center" | $80/yr.<br>  
| align="center" | $80/yr.<br>  
| <br>
| <br>
Line 140: Line 174:
| [http://www.photoloom.com/ Photoloom]<br>  
| [http://www.photoloom.com/ Photoloom]<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Artifacts<br>  
| align="center" | Free or $39/yr.<br>
| <br>  
| Users may store up to XX photographs for free.<br>
| align="center" | $39/yr.<br>  
|-
| Other affiliates<br>  
| align="center" | Aggregation<br>
| align="center" | <br>
| '''Needed: '''Someone needs to add the other NFS update certified programs.<br>
|}
 
== Collaboration Tools from Ancestry.com, Inc. and RootsWeb  ==
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1"
|+
|-
! scope="col" | Tool<br>
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>
! scope="col" | Cost<br>
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
|-
| [http://trees.ancestry.com Ancestry.com Member Trees]<br>
| align="center" | Artifacts, Tree results<br>
| align="center" | Free<br>
| Collaborators must be invited to make changes to the tree. Files can be up to 15 MB of types: text, MS.doc, PDF, jpg, png, gif, tiff, and bmp. No known storage space limit.<br>
|-
| [http://boards.ancestry.com/ Ancestry.com]/ [http://boards.rootsweb.com/ RootsWeb Message Boards]<br>
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts<br>
| align="center" | Free<br>
| Supports attachments of GEDCOM and some image files up to 4 MB. No known storage space limit.<br>
|-
| [http://genforum.genealogy.com GenForum]<br>
| align="center" | Communication<br>
| align="center" | Free<br>
| <br>
|}
 
== Other Collaboration Tools  ==
{| width="98%" cellspacing="1" cellpadding="1" border="1"
|+
|-
! scope="col" | Tool<br>
! scope="col" | Purpose<br>
! scope="col" | Cost<br>
! scope="col" | Notes<br>
|-
| [http://www.facebook.com/ Facebook]<br>
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts (low resolution), Aggregation<br>
| Free<br>
| '''Needed: '''someone to check the storage space available on Facebook. Also see <br>
|-
| [http://www.familylink.com/ FamilyLink.com]<br>
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts?, Aggregation<br>
| Free<br>
| '''Needed: '''someone to check this row of the table.<br>
|-
| [http://www.flickr.com/ Flickr]<br>
| align="center" | Artifacts<br>
| Free<br>
| 100 MB storage space.<br>
|-
| [http://www.fold3.com/ Fold3 People Pages]<br>
| align="center" | Artifacts, Aggregation<br>
| Free<br>
| File types: jpg, gif, tif, png upto 10 MB in size. No known storage limit.<br>
|-
| [http://www.photobucket.com/ Photobucket]<br>
| align="center" | Artifacts<br>
| Free<br>
| 10 GB/month download bandwidth limit. 500 MB storage space.<br>
|-
| [http://www.skype.com/ Skype]<br>
| align="center" | Communication<br>
| Free<br>
| '''Needed: '''someone to check this row of the table.<br>
|-
| [http://www.twitter.com/ Twitter]<br>
| align="center" | Communication<br>
| Free<br>
| Text only with 140 character message limit.<br>
|-
| [http://groups.yahoo.com/ Yahoo Groups]<br>
| align="center" | Communication, Artifacts, Aggregation<br>
| Free<br>  
| <br>
| <br>
|-
| Various free screen sharing and online meeting tools<br>
| align="center" | Communication<br>
| Free<br>
| '''Needed''': Someone needs to add the various free screen sharing and online meeting tools.<br>
|-
| Various online, free collaborative trees<br>
| align="center" | Aggregation<br>
| Free<br>
| '''Needed''': Someone needs to add the various free online collaborative trees.<br>
|}
|}


= Post Project Followup  =
&nbsp;* Requires an account for the New FamilySearch tree that will not be available to the general public until the months following the conference<br>
 
Following a research project, participants will want to go back through the results of the project, proof reading information, checking conclusions, and offering further research suggestions to the primary participant.
 
== Examples From Our Session  ==
 
*[http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=0AqSYSoDZfwK4dEdmekFkWFNVeThMZ3E1MDNQd1FzWGc&hl=en&single=true&gid=0&output=html Our research log]. This is the log of what we had scripted to do, not what you saw happen.
*[http://www.footnote.com/page/111153343_peyton_c_clements/ Results of our research using Footnote person pages]. Any registered user can make changes to these pages. We invite you to extend our results.
*[http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/17387474/person/503841443 Results of our research in an Ancestry.com member tree]. To see the results, you must have a subscription or you must be [http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/17387474/person/503841443 in the FamilySearch Library] or [http://trees.ancestrylibrary.com/tree/17387474/person/503841443 in a public library]. Only members of our research project team can make changes to these pages.


= Summary  =
= Summary  =


The desired outcome for this presentation is that you will take away the knowledge that research can be conducted in dramatically different ways than you may be used to doing. More people can participate, producing more artifacts and results in less time, making your valuable research time more productive.  
The desired outcome for this presentation is that you will take away the knowledge that research can be conducted in dramatically different ways than you may be used to doing. More people can participate, producing more artifacts and results in less time, making your valuable research time more productive.
 
[[Category:FamilySearch_Presentations_at_NGS_2010]]

Revision as of 17:07, 19 March 2010

NGS2010 125.png A presentation given by FamilySearch staff "Doing Research in Real Time-An Exhilarating Collaboration Experience!" (F308), at the National Genealogical Society 2010 conference in Salt Lake City, Utah. , presented by Alan E. Mann, AG®, Robert Raymond, and David E. Rencher, AG®, CGSM, FIGRS, FUGA .|}


This session illustrates how to do research collaboratively in real time using off-the-shelf products and services to accomplish more in less time and (we think) better results.

Collaboration[edit | edit source]

While our presentation focuses on the tools and benefits of real-time collaboration, the research process benefits from both real-time and non-real-time collaboration. Consider choosing real-time tools that give all the collaborators time for later absorption and analysis of the results. Hypotheses can then be added, reviewed and discussed asynchronously, leading to richer, fuller analysis, and eventually sounder conclusions. For example, an online research log allows for real-time sharing and assigning of research tasks, but also enables further collaboration.

Tools for Real-time Collaboration[edit | edit source]


Communication[edit | edit source]

These tools are used for "command and control" of a real time research session. This allows coordinated research activities. Assignments are given, results are reported, and a research log is produced. With this ability, the group is able to account for expected and unexpected results.

Artifacts[edit | edit source]

Artifact tools are used to share the documentary evidence that supports the research. These artifacts may include, but are not limited to: original vital records, probate, land, tax and other supporting evidence; photographs of tombstones, newspaper clippings – especially obituaries; summaries of oral interviews, etc. These artifacts need to be organized to tell the story and provide the evidentiary materials in such a way that other researchers have access to the materials for their own interpretation.

Aggregator[edit | edit source]

To aggregate the information streaming in from the various sources, an aggregation tool is necessary. This allows everyone to see the results of the research and to monitor progress. It also provides a critical analysis function by allowing visibility into the whole of the genealogical problem as it develops.

Tool Tables[edit | edit source]

Additions and corrections to these tables are encouraged. To qualify for inclusion, a tool must either be free or be FamilySearch Certified.

The tables in the conference syllabus use the term Tree Results instead of Aggregator. The tables here have been corrected. The conference syllabus only includes aggregators that provided their own collaborative tree. However, products certified to update the new FamilySearch Tree may be added to the tables below.

We invite everyone to monitor or contribute to the real-time research during the conference session. Tools and session participation links are subject to change. Check here before the session for the latest plans.

Collaboration Tools from Google[edit | edit source]

Tool
Purpose
Session Participation Link
Cost
Notes
Google Blogger
Communication Artifacts
NGS2010X Blog or E-mail
Free
HTML and images. Picasa has 1 GB limit.
Google Groups
Communication Artifacts

Free
Provides messaging and a file area for any file type. Uses upload throttling. 100 MB limit.
Google Docs
Communication Artifacts
Web Link
Free
Store any file type. 1 GB limit.
Google Gmail
Communication Artifacts

Free
Messages are private. Free storage space is 7 GB+.

Google Wave
 ?

Free
 ?
Google Buzz
Communication Artifacts

Free
Like Gmail, but messages can be shared. Same filesize limit as Gmail: 7 GB+.
Google Picasa
Artifacts

Free
1 GB limit.


Collaboration Tools from FamilySearch[edit | edit source]

Tool
Purpose
Session Participation Link
Cost
Notes
FamilySearch Wiki
See notes
https://integration-ru.familysearch.org/en/wiki/Doing_Research_in_Real_Time
Free
Textual information about locations and records can be entered into the wiki. Information about individuals and families should not.
FamilySearch Forums (beta)
Communication Artifacts
Search for tag: NGS2010X
Free
jpeg limited to 976 KB, other image formats are limited to 620 x 280.
New FamilySearch Tree*

Aggregation


Free

  * Not available to the general public until the months following the conference

Collaboration Tools from Certified FamilySearch Affiliates[edit | edit source]

Tool
Purpose
Session Participation Link
Cost
Notes
Ancestral Quest NetFam
Aggregation

$29.95
Online tree uses check-in/check-out to a desktop application
Appletree
Artifacts Aggregation

$59.40/yr

Arcalife
Artifacts Aggregation

Free or $250
limited or 10 GB
FamilyPursuit
Communication Artifacts† Aggregation

Free or
† 59.95/yr
1 GB
Mobiletree
Artifacts*

$4.99
iPhone application
One Great Family
Artifacts Aggregation

$80/yr.

Photoloom
Artifacts

$39/yr.

 * Requires an account for the New FamilySearch tree that will not be available to the general public until the months following the conference

Summary[edit | edit source]

The desired outcome for this presentation is that you will take away the knowledge that research can be conducted in dramatically different ways than you may be used to doing. More people can participate, producing more artifacts and results in less time, making your valuable research time more productive.